I Am Thomas - Theatre ☆☆☆☆4

Showing from - Friday, February 19, 2016 through till Saturday, February 27, 2016

Liverpool Playhouse - Liverpool

Johanna Roberts | Wednesday, February 24, 2016

I Am Thomas reviewed by Johanna Roberts on Wednesday, February 24, 2016 for Downstage CentreThought provoking and ingenious: Told By An Idiot give a grim tale a comic edge in 'I Am Thomas' at the Liverpool Playhouse this week (Photo by Manuel Harlan)

As the subtitle 'A Brutal Comedy With Songs' suggests, I am Thomas is just that. Indeed, the tale of Thomas Aikenhead, a medical student at Edinburgh University whose execution in 1697 made him the last person to be hanged for blasphemy in Great Britain, is bleak and grim.


But not unrelentingly so. In the hands of Told by an Idiot, it is also comic, and yes, there are songs.


The framework is a discussion about which of Edinburgh’s famous sons (or daughters!) deserves a statue on the fourth plinth and a quick trawl through the history books brings up the name of Aikenhead. As you would expect from Simon Armitage, the lyrics are layered and wittyAs the subsequent song makes clear, no one knows who he was, and so the story begins.

While the main set is a 17th century courtroom with scene changes cleverly effected by the use of back clothes and props, the switching between modern dress and period costume and the use of modern props indicate that the theme of free speech and the issue of capital punishment - for blasphemy or for being a threat to the state - resonate very much with contemporary society.


To demonstrate this universality, cultural references abound: to the Nazi state, the perennially menacing men in trench coats and sunglasses, and most specifically, to the Charlie Hebdo massacre - a point underlined by the role of Thomas being handed from actor to actor either by the use of t-shirts or in a macabre game of ‘pass the noose’.


Inventive and Innovative

The production has all the hallmarks of the company’s inventive and innovative style but you need to be on your toes to follow the interweaving of several stories throughout the structure. undefinedWhile the breaks for football style commentary on the events are clever (with nods to Alan Hansen and Shankly) and reflect historic attitudes to hanging as a public spectacle, they struck a discordant note with my teenage son who felt they broke the flow of the story. Indeed the production does sometimes feel a bit rough around the edges – perhaps deliberately so.


As you would expect from Simon Armitage, the lyrics are layered and witty. Some are taken from the transcript of the trial, where it was claimed Aikenhead had called theology ‘a rhapsody of feigned and ill-invented nonsense. Others, such as references to ‘Satan’s deep fat fryer’ and the congregation’s listing of the torments that await evil doers are juxtaposed with their clearly ironic claim that ‘God is love’. These hit darkly humorous notes. But there are also moments of extreme lyricism, enhanced by the musicianship and harmonies of the cast.


So, not a production for everyone (and certainly not one for the faint hearted), but it is thought-provoking, ingenious, and surprisingly funny.


Production Information

Theatre: Liverpool Playhouse

Showing Until: Saturday, February 27, 2016

Production Company: Told by an Idiot, the National Theatre of Scotland, Royal Lyceum Theatre Edinburgh, in association with Liverpool e&p

     MORE ARTICLES BY   Johanna Roberts

  • The Red Shed ☆☆☆☆☆

    Published: 16 Sep 2016


    ‘A good story well told’ – that’s all I ask from any book, play, opera, film, whatever. And that is what Mark Thomas, with his show to ce...

  • As You Like It ☆☆☆☆

    Published: 04 Jun 2016


    Summer’s here and the time is right for…open air theatre! And while, given the English summer, such ventures could be considered the triu...

  • The 39 Steps ☆☆☆☆

    Published: 05 Apr 2016


    The first laugh comes about two minutes in to this clever, engaging, and witty production, and from then on, the laughs keep coming.   Ba...

  • The Herbal Bed ☆☆☆☆

    Published: 09 Mar 2016


    Many is the time I’ve walked through John and Susannah Hall’s house in Stratford on Avon and many the afternoon I’ve sat in their beautif...

  • The Environmentalists ☆☆☆☆

    Published: 03 Mar 2016


    In a country that the Green Global Economy Index cites as suffering from ‘inconsistent and sometimes negative political rhetoric related ...

  • I Am Thomas ☆☆☆☆

    Published: 24 Feb 2016


    As the subtitle 'A Brutal Comedy With Songs' suggests, I am Thomas is just that. Indeed, the tale of Thomas Aikenhead, a medical student ...

Would you give "I Am Thomas" a ☆☆☆☆ rating?
Join the discussion and give us your view